15 Negotiation Ploys: Part Two
Calvin Johnson
Calvin Johnson
Special to Scout.com
Posted Jul 17, 2012


The second part of Alvin Grier's top negotiating strategies used by teams and players to reach a deal.

NFL Contracts – 15 Ways NFL Players and Teams Gain Leverage in Negotiations – Part Two
By Alvin Grier, Elite Sports Agency

Welcome back to our brief look into the different ways teams and players can gain leverage when it comes contract negotiations. Click here if you missed part one

Let’s pick up where we left off, and continue with number 7.

How Players Can Gain Leverage, Continued

 
 
7. Another Player of Similar (or Less) Ability Gets New Contract
 
If you’re in the midst of, or heading into contract negotiations, and a player that is of equal or less stature or ability (or whatever) gets a new, lucrative contract, it can give you more leverage.
 
Take Drew Brees’ situation for example.  Peyton Manning got a five-year $96 million deal from the Broncos, which gives him a $19.2 million average per year.
 
Up to that point, the Saints had reportedly offered Brees a deal that averaged a little over $18.5 million.
 
With Brees being younger and healthier, this gives Brees the leverage to ask for more.
 
I’m not sure what his demands are right now, but I’ve heard that he was seeking $23 million, which isn’t surprising, especially with the new leverage he’s attained from Peyton’s situation.
 
Not to mention that the Bountygate situation has stripped the Saints franchise of most of it’s leadership, so they need their quarterback more than ever now.
 
Not to mention he set the NFL passing record in 2011.

 
8. Having a Cap Number that Keeps the Team from Making Other Off Season Moves

Calvin Johnson is arguably the best receiver in the game, and he was about to be an unrestricted free agent after the 2012 season.
 
But despite those reasons, I’m pretty sure the $21.2 million cap number he was going to cost the Lions for the 2012 season was a major reason why he got that new deal.
 
If they didn’t give him a new deal, his cap number would’ve made it extremely difficult for the Lions to make any other roster acquisitions.
 
Now let’s take a look at how teams can gain leverage.
 
 
 
How NFL Teams Can Gain Leverage



9. Lack of a Market for Your Services on Other Teams
 
A good example of this is the Lions’ defensive end Cliff Avril.  He wants a long-term deal, but his chances of getting one dropped considerably after the 2012 NFL Draft.
 
All the teams that needed a defensive end either got one in the draft, or picked one up in free agency.
 
It’s not likely that the Lions will give him the long-term deal he wants; at least not yet.
 
 
10. Revealing Your Cards Destroys Your Leverage
 
I’m sure there’s a reason for this, and I’m sure his agent is brilliant, however Wes Welker publicly stating that he’s not going to miss any games in the 2012 season because of his contract removed any leverage he had for getting a new, long term deal done prior to the season.
 
Plus, he already signed his tender, so everyone knows he’s not going to hold out.
 
As I mentioned, this could be part of a larger plan between he and his agent, or it could very well be because Wes just flat out refuses to miss any games, or some other reason, like the $9.5 Million he’s going to make in 2012 from being franchised.


11. Drafting a Player at Your Position, Especially if They Do Well in OTA’s/Camp


Right now in 2012, Ray Rice wants a new deal.
 
With the numbers he put up last season, it’s hard to argue that he hasn’t outperformed his contract.
 
Even so, the Ravens drafted running back Bernard Pierce in the 2012 Draft, and if he does well in OTA’s and camp, the Ravens might be able to take a little of that leverage away from Ray.
 
We’ll have to wait and see how this one plays out.


12. Asking for a New Contract as an Exclusive-Rights Free Agent
 
The team also has the leverage if you’re trying to ask for a new contract while you’re an exclusive-rights free agent
 
Exclusive-rights free agents only have a couple years of accumulated experience, so they haven’t accumulated enough seasons in the NFL to be able to negotiate with other teams.
 
When you’re in this situation, the only team you can negotiate with is your current team, so you don’t have much leverage.
 
A good example of this is Fred Jackson from the Bills, and his previous contract, that he wasn’t happy with.
 
He was an exclusive-rights free agent when he signed that previous deal, and wasn’t really in a position to ask for much more than what the Bills were going to give him.
 
 
 
13. Teams Play the Injury/Durability Concern Card
 
This one is used by teams pretty often, but it’s most easily used on running backs.
 
A team can gain the leverage if there’s injury or durability concerns, especially if the team has already brought in a potential replacement.
 
Especially if you’re getting up there in age.  Take Matt Forte for example.
 
Many believe the Bears have (at the time when I’m typing this) gained leverage on Matt largely due to him missing four games in the 2011 season due to injuries, and the fact that he missed quite a few games at Tulane in college due to injuries.
 
Take all of that into consideration, and the Bears just might hold the leverage in that situation.
 
Especially after bringing in Michael Bush.
 

14. Player Has Multiple Years Left on Contract
 
A team can gain the leverage when/if you want a new deal and you have multiple years left on your contract.
 
A good example of this one is the Maurice Jones-Drew situation.
 
Heading into the 2012 season, he wants a new contract, but the truth is that the Jaguars have him locked up for another two seasons from the 5-year deal he signed before the 2009 season.
 
On top of that, the Jaguars could franchise him, and if they did, they’d have his rights for another three years.
 
 
15. Team Has Depth at Your Position
 
If a team has depth at your position, it can hurt your leverage if you’re trying to hold out for a new deal.
 
In 2010, when Revis was holding out for a new deal, Kyle Wilson, the first round draft pick at corner was doing great in training camp.
 They also had Marquise Cole and Drew Coleman and a few other players that were doing well.
 
If the player was anyone else other than Darrelle Revis, that depth at the cornerback position just might’ve been enough to convince the Jets that they would move forward into the season without him.
 
But, it wasn’t anyone else; it was Darrelle Revis.

Don't Miss Part One


Grier's colums appear  on Scout.com reprinted with permission. You can read more at Get2TheLeague.com

Alvin Grier serves as the Director of Midwest Operations for Elite Sports Agency (ESA), that services 15 current NFL players, and several UFL and CFL players.  As a collegiate football player, Alvin earned his Bachelors and Masters of Science degrees (in Information Technology) from Ferris State University. (Bio), you can also find him on Twitter @alvingrier, or facebook: Get2TheLeague 




Related Stories
Saints ink Drew Brees to $100 million deal
 -by ScoutNFLNetwork.com  Jul 13, 2012
League Relaxes Blackout Rule
 -by PatriotsInsider.com  Jul 2, 2012
Players React To Saints Punishment
 -by PatriotsInsider.com  Mar 22, 2012

PREMIUM SUBSCRIPTION INCLUDES
> Members-only Forums
> Insider Information
> Free Agency &
   Draft News
> Expert Chats

Sign Up Today!

Free Email Newsletter
Don't miss any news or features from PatriotsInsider.com. Subscribe to our newsletter to have our newest articles emailed to you on a daily or weekly basis.
Click here for a list of all Team Newsletters.

Add Players to My HotList
Get free email alerts with news about your favorite players. Click name to add to My HotList.
QB Drew Brees (profile)
[View My HotList]